Truths, which we ignore about Abrahamic religions

While studying and comparing multiple religious systems, we, the Hindus, are often confused between two concepts, or say, two ideologies - Monotheism and Monism.
Now let's take a look at the types into which religions are divided by scholars.
Basically there are two types of religions on the basis of number of entities they worship- Monotheistic and Polytheistic.
If you use Google translate on web, translation of Monotheism given there is
Ekeshwarwaad (एकेश्वरवाद), i.e. the ideology which worships one ultimate entity (whatever be it's name, but it's ultimate source of everything). If you use Google translate to translate Polytheism, it says BAHUDEVA-VAAD (बहुदेववाद). Be careful, here's a dangerous turn, make no mistake. Meaning of polytheism is an ideology which worships multiple deities,( Devi-Devata) and it's not the worship of multiple ultimate entities, because if an entity has to be ultimate, it can only be one and not many, that is why we the Hindus, use the terms like paramatma (परमात्मा), the ultimate soul. So, if the term polytheism means worship of multiple deities, i.e. Devi and Devatas, how can the term Monotheism mean workship of one single ultimate entity and not one single deity, while the basis of this classification of religions is the number of entities worshipped. This is the sole reason why Christianity Christianity and Islam are monotheistic and not monistic. Again the question arises that why do I need to mention this? This is because we the Hindus, and many others like us, tend to think or assume that God or Allah are general terms for the ultimate entity, or say we tend to assume that there two words are English/Arabic terms for paramatma(परमात्मा)  or Ishwar (ईश्वर). The term God comes from the  Proto-Germanic   ǥuđan. The Germanic word in its originality was gender neutral. But when it was appropriated by English language, it became synonymous to one male entity named Jehovah, the Christian creator. This creator, is not a source of the universe but actually a real walking being who created everything as if a carpenter created furniture. Worship of God or in other words Jehovah is not the worship or invoking of the ultimate source of the world, but it's submission of Christian version of a deity who is supposedly the creator of the world in their version of creation. Then comes Allah, (Arabic: الله). If you read what is written on the flag of Saudi Arabia over a sword, it says, "None deserves worship except Allah, and Muhammad is the messenger of Allah". (Arabic: La ilaha illallah
Muhammadun rasulu'llah) This particular phrase is called shahada, or oath, which one takes while converting to Islam. Note that here, it's mentioned "Worship". Logic says, that the term worship can only be used with a walking being and not with a shapeless formless entity. The God (or Jehovah) of Christianity and the Allah of Islam are the names of their version of creator contrary to popular perception that assumes them to be the general term for ultimate supreme source of existence. While Hindu version is that Paramatma, the ultimate soul is one and can be known by different names by different wise people and sages of the world, the Islamic version says that the only creator of everything is Allah and only Allah, and he can't be known as any other name except Allah or the names prescribed in the Quran, and same goes with Christianity with respect to the God(Or Jehovah). While a Hindu or Hindu scriptures on one hand, thinks that, Vishnu, Shiva, Brahma, Kartikeya, Durga etc are nothing but manifestation of one supreme source of the universe, the Muslims and Islamic theology thinks that Allah is the only worship worthy entity, and all the other entities, from Shiva to Jehovah are false gods, symbols of infidelity, act of Satan (devil), mere imagination of fools, and so on. Islam or Christianity simply denies existence of any other entity except Allah or God and tends to falsify them. Let's try to understand this with one final example. For a Hindu, the ultimate soul or Paramatma or Ishwar, is an ocean. All the Devi and Devatas and other versions of the creator or deities which are worshipped, are the rivers which will ultimately fall into the ocean. While for a Muslim or a Christian, Allah or God are the only isolated ponds, and for them, there are no other water resource in existence and no stream of water anywhere remotely connecting with their pond and any other water source mentioned out of their theology is non existent or false water resource.
This entire theory is to explain that the unity of God (loosely speaking) in Abrahamic religions, Islam or Christianity, isn't the underlying unity of all worshipped entities, but it is the only singularity in existence which is supposed to be worshipped clearly explaining why they are Monotheistic and not monistic. This also breaks down the narrative that all religions propagate the same thought and thus proves that all religions, contrary to popular perception among liberals, aren't the same.

And those who promote this nonsense, that all religions are the same, are civilizational threats, even if unknowingly so.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

A truth that no one discusses

The Moral High Ground- I

They leave Abrahamism, Abraham doesn't leave them